Date of Hearing |
Member Name |
Membership Number |
Charge |
Penalty |
13/06/2024 | Mrs Anne Muscat | 3008556530 | Breach of VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Regulation 4.1.3.1.2 | Reprimand. Good behaviour for 6 months. |
17/06/2024 | Mrs Jean Purcell | 3100026616 |
Breach of VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Rule 2.19, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.21, VCA Code of Practice 20.3.2.6, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.22.1, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.22.1.1 |
Good behaviour for a period of six months commencing 17 June 2024. The period of good behaviour will be discharged after 6 months on the specific condition that; a. The Respondent fulfils the undertaking she voluntarily gave to DV during the discipline hearing on 17 June 2024 to “make right” by reimbursing the complainant the sum $3500 (cost of the puppy). Prior to the expiration of 6 months, the Respondent is required to write to DV and provide proof that the payment was made to the complainant. |
18/06/2024 | Mr Shaun Schembri | 3100049913 | Breach of VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.25.3 | Good behaviour for a period of twelve months commencing 19 June 2024. If no further breach occurs within the 12 months, there will be no further penalty. If a further breach occurs, the Respondent will be imposed with a 6 month suspension. Within 31 days a refund for the puppy and vet costs must be paid to the complainant and proof provided to Dogs Victoria. Failure to make payment will be a breach of good behaviour. |
20/06/2024 | Mrs Rhonda Dearnaley | 3003007940 | Breach of VCA Rule 2.17, DA Regulations Part 5 – 2.1.1, DA Regulations Part 5 – 2.3.4, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.1 | Suspended for the duration of 6 months - from 20 June 2024 to 20 December 2024 + $250 fine |
8/07/2024 | Ms Yvonne Ross | 3009925520 | Breach of VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.3, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.30 |
Good behaviour for a period of twelve months commencing 8 July 2024. The penalty will be discharged after 12 months provided the Respondent continues to be of good behaviour during that period. In the event that the Respondent breaches this order within 12 months by committing any further contravention(s), the Respondent will be brought back before this same Disciplinary Committee and an appropriate sanction will then be issued for contraventions of the charges. |
13/06/2023 |
Mrs Helen Holmes |
3100020675 |
Breach VCA Rule 2.17; VCA COP 20.1.1 |
Three (3) months suspension wholly suspended for a period of twelve (12) months effective from 13 June 2023. |
03/03/2023 | Mr John Waddell | 3100050490 |
VCA Rule 2.17; VCA CoP 20.1.14.1 – Related Mating |
$500 fine |
15/03/2023 |
Andrew Maghamez |
3100030212 |
Breach VCA Rule 2.17; VCA COP 20.1.15.1 |
Six months suspension & $500 fine |
18/08/2023 |
Mrs Paula Semmel |
3100001244 |
VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.2; 20.1.3 |
12 months suspension commencing 18/08/2023 + $500 fine |
30/05/2023 |
Mrs Barbara Slavin |
3100036053 |
Breach of VCA Rule 2.17 Breach of VCA Regulations 4.1.3.1.1; 4.1.3.1.2 Breach of VCA COP 20.1.13 |
12 Months Suspension + $500 Fine - Fine Paid |
28/11/2023 |
Mrs Julie Clarke |
3100066349 |
Breach VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.1; 20.1.2 VCA Reg 4.2.7 |
24 months suspension from 28/11/2023 with 12 months suspended providing no further breach occurs + $500 fine. Fine to be paid in full within two calendar months. Fine paid on 22/01/2024. Regulation 5.6.4 applies. Any penalty involving ineligibility, disqualification or suspension imposed on a member shall also apply to all dogs registered in the name of or owned or part owned or leased or part leased by that member |
23/01/2024 |
Mrs Tracey Moore |
3100023776 |
Breach of VCA Admin Suspension Rule 2.11.2. |
Admin Suspension - Failing to respond for Pedigree Demand. |
08/02/2024 |
Mrs Teresa Vaughan |
3100014650 | Breach VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.21; 20.1.23.8; 20.1.25; 20.1.22.1; 20.1.22.1.1 |
12 months suspension from 08/02/2024 + $500 fine, Fine to be paid in full within one calendar month from 08/02/2024. Regulation 5.6.5 applies - Where a fine payable within a specified period has been imposed on a member by a Disciplinary Hearing and the fine has not been paid within the specified period, the member's membership shall be suspended until such time as the fine is paid |
12/02/2024 | Mrs Marlene McKinney | 3100048299 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.15 | Three (3) month suspension from 12/02/2024 + $500 fine. Fine Paid. |
16/02/2024 | Mr Truc Huynh | 3100045694 | Breach of VCA Admin Suspension Rule 2.11.2. | Admin Suspension - Failing to respond to Pedigree Demand. |
29/02/2024 | Mr Matthew Caval | 3100042155 | Breach of VCA Admin Suspension Rule 2.11.2. | Admin Suspension - Failing to respond to compliance request. |
20/02/2024 | Ms Sue Menzel | 3000036750 | Breach VCA Rule 2.17; VCA Reg 4.1.3.16 | Three months suspension wholly suspended for a period of 12 months effective from 20 February 2024. |
14/02/2024 | Mr Michael Dawood | 3100034441 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.21; 20.1.22.1; 20.1.23.1;20.1.23.2 | Six(6) months suspension from 14/02/2024 + $500 fine. |
12/03/2024 | Mrs Eileen Li | 3100063599 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Regulation 4.1.3.16; VCA Code of Practice 20.1.15 | wholly suspended for 18 months: In the event a further breach occurs within the next 18 months from 13/03/2024, both the $500 fine and suspension will be imposed. |
14/03/2024 | Mr Matthew Caval | 3100042155 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Regulations 4.4.4; 4.4.6, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.26.3 | Suspension for the duration of 12 months effective from the date the current Admin suspension is lifted. |
19/03/2024 | Ms Emma McDonald | 3100042155 |
VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Regulations 4.1.3.1.1, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.15; 20.1.26.3 |
12 months suspension - From 19 March 2024 till 19 March 2025 +$500 fine Invoice be paid within one month. If not, an extension of 6 months' suspension will be required. Fine paid 26/03/2024. |
21/03/2024 | Mrs Sharon Lang | 3100036062 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.15 | Reprimand. |
21/03/2024 | Mr John & Mrs Dawn Wilders | 3008349480 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.15 | 3 (three) months suspension, wholly suspended for 12 months proving no further breaches occur from 22/03/2024 till 21/03/2025 |
26/03/2024 | Mr Omer Omer | 3100061284 |
VCA Rule 2.17 VCA Code of Practice COP 20.1.2; 20.1.4;20.1.5.1; 20.1.5.2; 20.1.5.3; 20.1.5.4; 20.1.11; 20.1.22.1; 20.1.22.1.1; 20.1.22.1.2; 20.1.22.2; 20.1.23.4; 20.1.29; 20.8.1; 20.8.2; 20.8.3; 20.8.4; 20.8.5 VCA Reg 4.1.3.1.1; 4.1.3.1.2; 4.4.4 |
Termination of membership and prefix EXQUISITETOY with a lifetime ban from rejoining + $500 fine to be paid in full prior to any puppy being eligible for registration. |
27/03/2024 | Mr Ferdi Muaremov | 3100036492 | VCA Rule 2.17, VCA Code of Practice 20.1.12 | 12-month suspension effective 26/03/2024 + $500 fine. |
26/04/2024 | Miss Jamie Hogg | 3100035216 | Breach of VCA Admin Suspension Rule 2.11.2. | Admin Suspension - Failing to respond to Pedigree Demand. |